[RESULT] HX-D2 vs F#1 Status vs CD700 vs P9
Scuto Laminating Blackvue HD Car Care

25 Mei 2016 - Payment System Terbaru Untuk Bursa Jual Beli telah kami hadirkan.
Untuk informasi lebih lengkap dapat dilihat di http://modifika.si/630917

Page 1 of 8 12345 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 76
  • Thread Tools
  • Short URL:  http://modifika.si/2792
  • Share on facebook
  • Share on twitter
  1. #1
    Sersan Satu
    Location
    melbz
    Posts
    361
    Power
    M-Store Point
    0
    Online
    N/A

    [RESULT] HX-D2 vs F#1 Status vs CD700 vs P9

    ini dapet forum car audio di amrik
    Ini back to back test untuk the following head unit:
    HX-D2
    F#1 Status
    CD700II
    P9

    Test ini dijalankan oleh 3 org in home environment not car. berikut komentar dari 3 org tsb. see below ada 3 quotes.

    RESULT:
    I rated them after listening in this order:


    1) Clarion
    2) Nak CD700II
    3) F#1
    4) P9


    The Clarion and great stage depth and tonal accuracy without being coloured or bass heavy. Great focus and separation between instruments. Lovely top end and gave a linear sound.

    The Nak was very similar to the Clarion, but had slightly more midbass. The depth wasn't as good, but sounded slightly warmer. Good focus, but not quite the detail of the Clarion.

    F#1 was very warm, but lacked depth. Maybe too midbass heavy, but was full of energy. Focus was good, but lacked some detail. Slightly sibilant and the top end wasn't quite as good as the others.

    P9 was clinical and accurate with good depth. But lack midbass and emotion. Good focus, but separation was relatively poor.

    I rated the Clarion as the best due to the features and VFM. The Nak sounded slightly better, but the crossover and EQ made up for it. There wasn't too much in the sound.

    The F#1 was nice, but too warm for me. Puts a smile on your face and is toe tapping good, but I wondered whether this was just the extra midbass. A very Alpine sound Smile

    P9 was nice, but not involving and wasn't that transparent.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------


    1) F#1
    2) Clarion
    3) Naka
    4) P9


    In last place was the P9. This possibly had the greatest depth of sound stage of all of them. It was very easy to place instruments from the front to the back. However, as Si said, it was a little too clinical in its presentation of the music. A little light on the midbass.

    In joint 2nd place I'd put the Clarion and Nak. Both portrayed the sound in a similar way to what Si has already said. The Nak has slighly better midbass where as the Clarion offers better value for money. The Clarions sound stage height seemed a little lower.

    In first place I'd put the F1. Whilst it had the shallowest sound stage depth it was on the one that got my foot tapping with every track. It had more soul. A HU may present more detail and sound very boring, the F1 it certainly not boring. It did seem to suffer slightly from sibilance.

    What would be interesting would be too try my 7969 to see whether it has the same sonic characteristics as the F1. Unfortunately we ran out of time. Another interesting test would be to use the F1 processor connected to both F1 HU and my 7969 - would there be any difference?

    We also didn't get a chance to try the Rockford HU. Others worth trying are the Denon Z1 and Mac.

    Obviously the F1 is the most expensive here and is comparable to the Nak when it comes to features. If you've after an all in one box I'd suggest the Clarion, if you're after the most musical HU go for the F1.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------


    Alpine F1 - king for rythm, pace and energy. The top and bottom ends were a little over emphasised, which I feel was the reason it seemed to portray a better sense of energy.. definitely the foot tapper. All this at the complete expense of staging and imaging... this is real flat earth.
    Touchy feely - this was bottom of the league, the volume pot was very disapointing.. cd mech fine.

    Nak CD700ii - Overall winner, a more involving sound that the clarion, staging not quite so good, but definitely my overall favorite for all qualities being well represented.
    Touchy feely - very nice, on a par with the Clarion, but cd mech sounded like a death rattle.

    Clarion DRZ9255 - Wow, what a unit, throw in the processing power, and the cheap price tag, and to my ears there is no contest. Extremely transparant, exceptional staging and imaging, and very linear.
    Touchy feely - Very nice, eject mech extremely smooth, and volume pot to die for.

    Pioneer - Just old now I think, and outclassed by the newer releases.. extremely forced sound - very processed. Not something that I could listen to for very long.
    Touchy feely - nothing to fault, nohing to praise really.
    MODSTER Motorsport
    - Master of Modifications -

  2. Rekeningku.com
  3. #2
    Kapten
    Location
    Surabaya
    Posts
    2,875
    Power
    M-Store Point
    0
    Online
    1 Hr 28 Mins 10 Secs
    kesimpulan 3 ahli di atas berarti HXD2 paleng bagus dan natural. best buy de..
    Alpine CDA 9815 + volt stabilizer (DIY)
    Ciare CT250 + ceramic midrange (DIY) + Ciare CW171
    Helix HXA500 ++
    10" Carbon fibre subwoofer (DIY)
    Capasitor Banks (DIY)
    Cables by Flux

  4. #3
    Sersan Satu
    Location
    melbz
    Posts
    361
    Power
    M-Store Point
    0
    Online
    N/A
    Yup.

    HX-D2, CD700II dan F1 Status sepertinya lumayan a tough competition.

    P9 paling bawah dari opini 3 org tsb
    MODSTER Motorsport
    - Master of Modifications -

  5. #4
    Kapten
    Location
    Surabaya
    Posts
    2,875
    Power
    M-Store Point
    0
    Online
    1 Hr 28 Mins 10 Secs
    melihat harga, model dan fungsionalitasnya si..
    menurut gue mending HXD2 de..
    Alpine CDA 9815 + volt stabilizer (DIY)
    Ciare CT250 + ceramic midrange (DIY) + Ciare CW171
    Helix HXA500 ++
    10" Carbon fibre subwoofer (DIY)
    Capasitor Banks (DIY)
    Cables by Flux

  6. #5
    Letnan Satu
    Location
    JAKARTA
    Posts
    1,659
    Power
    M-Store Point
    0
    Online
    3 Hrs 11 Mins 20 Secs
    yup, hx-d2 bener2 value for money.
    klo emang ada duit lebih sih emang mending F1 status hehehe...
    under construction...

  7. #6

  8. #7
    stereo4u
    Guest
    kalo ada kesempatan denger suara ke 4 nya dlm waktu bersamaan mau ngak...?

  9. #8
    Letnan Satu
    Location
    JAKARTA
    Posts
    1,659
    Power
    M-Store Point
    0
    Online
    3 Hrs 11 Mins 20 Secs
    mau dong boss, lo bisa ngasih kita kesempatan itu ya?hehehe...
    under construction...

  10. #9
    stereo4u
    Guest
    he..he..I wish I could provide u that...

  11. #10
    Letnan Satu
    Location
    jakarta
    Posts
    1,869
    Power
    M-Store Point
    0
    Online
    1 Wk 1 Day 20 Hrs 53 Mins 33 Secs
    wah asik neh bsa denger ke 4nya bersamaan hehe...mau dunk bos hoho..

 

 
Page 1 of 8 12345 ... LastLast
NGK Busi Wuling

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. WTS 2ND: ALPINE F1 STATUS LAMA & F1 STATUS BARU
    By halim_adi in forum Head Unit & Processor
    Replies: 4
    Last Post: 29th January 2012, 13:31
  2. WTB: Nakamichi CD700 MK2
    By Civic_vi in forum Head Unit & Processor
    Replies: 12
    Last Post: 19th June 2011, 11:52
  3. WTS: Nakamichi CD700 MK1
    By Civic_vi in forum Head Unit & Processor
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 13th December 2010, 15:51
  4. Nakamichi cd700 mk1
    By nadim in forum Head Unit & Processor
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 2nd November 2010, 19:23
  5. NAKA CD700 MK1
    By nicric in forum Head Unit & Processor
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 21st June 2010, 08:12
Back to top